Annexation of the Kyiv Metropolis by the Moscow Patriarchate (1685–1690)

The annexation of the independent Ukrainian church through diplomatic pressure and corruption. Patriarch Dositheos of Jerusalem directly accused the Muscovite envoys of simony: "What [kind of] right is it to snatch away someone else's eparchy? Is it not a shame before people, is it not a sin before God! Thus you send money and lead people astray from their reason..."[1]. The subjugation of the church was justified by geopolitics: "Golitsyn's main project... was the reform of the Ukrainian Orthodox church, or rather, the subordination of the Kyiv metropolis to the Moscow patriarch"[2].

ID: C0008
Start:  January 1685
End:  December 1686
Version: 1.0
Created: 24 April 2026
Last Modified: 24 April 2026

Actors

ID Name Description
G0008 Tsardom of Muscovy

To gain control over the church, Moscow employed corruption at the international level. "The Kyiv Metropolitanate was seized... through bribery, manipulation, blackmail..." [3]. The envoy of Constantinople "directly asked the Muscovite envoy for money in exchange for issuing the required charter"[1][4].

Techniques Used

ID Name Use
T0015 Bribery of Elites

To gain control over the church, Moscow employed corruption at the international level. "The Kyiv Metropolitanate was seized... through bribery, manipulation, blackmail..." [3]. The envoy of Constantinople "directly asked the Muscovite envoy for money in exchange for issuing the required charter"[1][4].

T0101 Censorship

The introduction of censorship control over Ukrainian book printing. Patriarch Joachim prohibited publications without his sanction and sent a "reprimand for publishing books without prior permission." "The anathema of the Russian Orthodox Church on church books printed in the Ukrainian literary language of the time"[5]. [2][6].

T0044 Destruction of Local Knowledge Systems

The destruction of the Kyiv theological school and the declaration of its works as heresy: "All Ukrainian writings, beginning with the catechism of Petro Mohyla, were declared heretical... the council condemned virtually all the principal works of Kyivan theological scholarship"[6][2].

T0024 Justification Through Religion

The annexation of the metropolitanate was disguised as the protection of co-religionists. The reform was carried out "relying on the Orthodox movement against the Turkish conquerors... Golitsyn's main project became the subordination of the Kyiv metropolitanate"[2][1][6].

T0116 Religious Assimilation

Immediately after the subordination began the imposition of Muscovite church standards and rites, which led to the marginalization of local culture. This ecclesiastical absorption "was the beginning... of the Russification of Ukraine"[3][1].

.003 Ban on Worship in the Native Language

Following the establishment of control over the metropolitanate came a gradual ban on the use of the Kyivan recension of Church Slavonic and of Ukrainian pronunciation in liturgy and books, which laid the foundation for the complete language bans of the 18th century[1].

T0100 Seizure of Religious Institutions

The liquidation of independent jurisdiction to turn the church into an instrument of assimilation: "The annexation of the Ukrainian church to the Muscovite church in 1686" [3]. Moreover, these actions "were carried out not at all in accordance with lawful canonical prescriptions"[1][6].

Instruments

ID Name Description
S0009 Diplomacy

To gain control over the church, Moscow employed corruption at the international level. "The Kyiv Metropolitanate was seized... through bribery, manipulation, blackmail..." [3]. The envoy of Constantinople "directly asked the Muscovite envoy for money in exchange for issuing the required charter"[1][4].

S0011 Moscow Patriarchate

The liquidation of independent jurisdiction to turn the church into an instrument of assimilation: "The annexation of the Ukrainian church to the Muscovite church in 1686" [3]. Moreover, these actions "were carried out not at all in accordance with lawful canonical prescriptions"[1][6].

References